| All-Americans | ||||
| 2006 | HM-Tugberk Tekdemir | |||
| All-Conference | ||||
| 1996 | 2nd-Luke Windy | |||
| 1998 | HM-Adam Zgoda | |||
| HM-Jason Kisor | ||||
| HM-Mike Bruggeman | ||||
| HM-Nate Browne | ||||
| Note: Penn changed to NAIA/MCC in 2001 | ||||
| 2001 | 2nd-Derek D'Agosta | |||
| 2nd-Joe Druppel | ||||
| HM-James McDermott | ||||
| 2002 | 1st-Adam Densley | |||
| 2nd-Joe Druppel | ||||
| 2nd-Brian Johson | ||||
| HM-Matt Atencio | ||||
| HM-Randy Albright | ||||
| HM-Brandon Ghidossi | ||||
| HM-Kory Klotz | ||||
| HM-Nicholas Velarde | ||||
| 2003 | 2nd-Randy Albright | |||
| 2nd-Matt Atencio | ||||
| 2nd-Frankie Gonzalez | ||||
| 2nd-Justin Barker | ||||
| HM-Nick Howlett | ||||
| HM-Tyler Lawrence | ||||
| 2004 | 1st-Brandon Ermels | |||
| 2nd-Joe Druppel | ||||
| 2nd-Archie Hoggan | ||||
| HM-Kenny DeCook | ||||
| HM-Tugberk Tekdemir | ||||
| HM-Tomaz Lain | ||||
| Newcomer-Kenny DeCook | ||||
| 2005 | 1st-Nik Rule | |||
| 1st-Tugberk Tekdemir | ||||
| 2nd-Jeff Wolfe | ||||
| Newcomer-Nik Rule | ||||
| 2006 | 1st-Nik Rule | |||
| 1st-Tugberk Tekdemir | ||||
| 2nd-Edin Sabic | ||||
| 2nd-Amando Irias | ||||
| HM-Eli Bradley | ||||
| HM-Guadalupe Garcia | ||||
| HM-Fernando Sanchez | ||||
| HM-Eric Rinkema | ||||