| 1996 | ||||||
| Southeastern CC | W | 3-2 | ||||
| Augustana | L | 0-17 | ||||
| Faith Baptist | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Iowa Central | L | 2-6 | ||||
| Waldorf | L | 0-6 | ||||
| Augustana | L | 0-9 | ||||
| Grace | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Westminster | L | 0-6 | ||||
| Iowa Central | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Wartburg | L | 0-9 | ||||
| Southeastern CC | W | 5-1 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy | L | 0-6 | ||||
| Central | L | 0-5 | ||||
| Central | L | 0-7 | ||||
| Head Coach: Bill Collman | ||||||
| Record: 2-12 | ||||||
| 1997 | ||||||
| Southeastern CC | W | 3-2 | ||||
| Waldorf | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Westminster | W | 4-3 | ||||
| Doane | L | 2-5 | ||||
| Loras* | L | 2-4 | ||||
| Cornell* | W | 2-0 | ||||
| Buena Vista* | W | 3-2 | ||||
| Coe* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Central* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Wartburg* | L | 1-6 | ||||
| Luther* | L | 1-6 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Upper Iowa* | W | 8-1 | ||||
| Simpson* | L | 0-5 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Head Coach: Bill Collman | ||||||
| Record: 6-9 (3-6 IIAC) | ||||||
| 1998 | ||||||
| Southeastern CC | W | 5-0 | ||||
| Grand View | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan | W | 4-2 | ||||
| Central Methodist | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Westminster | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Luther* | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Hannibal-LaGrange | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Simpson* | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Wartburg* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Cornell* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Loras* | L | 0-5 | ||||
| Buena Vista* | T | 0-0 | ||||
| Coe* | L | 0-8 | ||||
| Upper Iowa* | W | 4-2 | ||||
| Central* | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Head Coach: Bill Collman | ||||||
| Record: 5-10-1 (2-6-1 IIAC) | ||||||
| 1999 | ||||||
| Iowa Wesleyan | L | 1-5 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy | L | 0-8 | ||||
| Rose Hulman | L | 0-9 | ||||
| Wartburg* | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Luther* | L | 0-10 | ||||
| Simpson* | L | 0-11 | ||||
| Faith Baptist | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Central* | L | 0-6 | ||||
| Augustana | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Mt. St. Clare | L | 0-6 | ||||
| Cornell* | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Buena Vista* | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Loras* | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Upper Iowa* | L | 1-6 | ||||
| Coe* | L | 0-8 | ||||
| Grand View | L | 0-8 | ||||
| Head Coach: Bill Collman | ||||||
| Record: 0-16 (0-9 IIAC) | ||||||
| 2000 | ||||||
| Crown | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Wartburg* | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Luther* | L | 1-7 | ||||
| Augustana | L | 1-3 | ||||
| Simpson* | L | 1-8 | ||||
| Central* | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Clarke | W | 7-3 | ||||
| Cornell* | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Faith Baptist | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Buena Vista* | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Loras* | L | 2-7 | ||||
| Upper Iowa* | L | 2-5 | ||||
| Coe* | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Head Coach: Ammon Bennett | ||||||
| Record: 2-13 (1-8 IIAC) | ||||||
| 2001 | ||||||
| William Woods | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Illinois College | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Hannibal-LaGrange | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Central Methodist | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Augustana | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Marycrest* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Viterbo* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy* | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Faith Baptist | W | 6-1 | ||||
| Briar Cliff | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Mt. St. Clare* | T | 2-2 | ||||
| St. Xavier | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Marycrest% | W | 5-4 | ||||
| Viterbo% | L | 2-3 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: Ammon Bennett | ||||||
| Record: 5-11-1 (1-5-1 MCC) | ||||||
| 2002 | ||||||
| William Woods | L | 1-2 | ||||
| St. Xavier | W | 4-2 | ||||
| Hannibal-LaGrange | W | 5-0 | ||||
| Briar Cliff | W | 5-0 | ||||
| Mt. St. Clare* | W | 7-1 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy* | W | 2-0 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | T | 1-1 | ||||
| Central Methodist | W | 4-1 | ||||
| Viterbo* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 1-3 | ||||
| Faith Baptist | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Grinnell | W | 3-2 | ||||
| Friends | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | T | 1-1 | ||||
| Huron | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy% | W | 6-2 | ||||
| Grand View% | W | 2-1 | ||||
| St. Ambrose% | L | 0-3 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: Ammon Bennett | ||||||
| Record: 11-5-2 (2-2-2 MCC) | ||||||
| 2003 | ||||||
| St. Xavier | T | 1-1 | ||||
| Friends | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Kendall | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Trinity International | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Missouri Baptist | L | 0-4 | ||||
| Truman State | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Cornell | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Waldorf* | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Franciscan* | W | 3-1 | ||||
| St. Francis | W | 6-0 | ||||
| Viterbo* | W | 4-3 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | W | 3-2 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy* | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Franciscan% | W | 4-1 | ||||
| St. Ambrose% | L | 1-5 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: Steve Golas | ||||||
| Record: 10-6-1 (5-2 MCC) | ||||||
| 2004 | ||||||
| St. Xavier | L | 1-2 | ||||
| William Woods | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Northwestern | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Cornell | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Cardinal Stritch | L | 1-3 | ||||
| Olivet Nazarene | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Hannibal-LaGrange | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy* | W | 4-3 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 3-7 | ||||
| Waldorf* | W | 5-1 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Crossroads Bible | W | 6-0 | ||||
| Franciscan* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Viterbo* | W | 5-1 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Illinois Tech | T | 2-2 | ||||
| Trinity International | L | 0-8 | ||||
| Upper Iowa | W | 9-3 | ||||
| The Franciscan% | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Grand View% | L | 1-5 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: Ken DeCook | ||||||
| Record: 7-12-1 (3-4 MCC) | ||||||
| 2005 | ||||||
| Concordia | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Illinois Tech | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Wisconsin Lutheran | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Midland Lutheran | L | 0-3 | ||||
| St. Francis | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Dana | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Taylor | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Crossroads Bible | W | 6-0 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | L | 1-3 | ||||
| Mt. Mercy* | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Viterbo* | W | 2-0 | ||||
| Waldorf* | W | 7-0 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | W | 2-1 | ||||
| Ashford* | W | 4-1 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Upper Iowa | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Mount Mercy% | W | 1-0 | ||||
| St. Ambrose% | L | 0-2 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: John Egan | ||||||
| Record: 8-10 (5-2 MCC) | ||||||
| 2006 | ||||||
| Midland Lutheran | WOT | 2-1 | ||||
| Briar Cliff | W | 3-0 | ||||
| Culver-Stockton | W | 3-1 | ||||
| Trinity International | L | 0-2 | ||||
| Saint Xavier | L | 0-3 | ||||
| Simpson | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Olivet Nazarene | L | 0-1 | ||||
| Coe | W | 5-0 | ||||
| Mount Mercy* | W | 2-0 | ||||
| St. Ambrose* | L | 1-2 | ||||
| Viterbo* | W | 4-3 | ||||
| Iowa Wesleyan* | L | 2-3 | ||||
| Ashford* | L2OT | 2-3 | ||||
| Crossroads Bible | W | 15-0 | ||||
| Upper Iowa | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Waldorf* | W | 4-1 | ||||
| Grand View* | L | 1-4 | ||||
| Robert Morris | W | 5-0 | ||||
| Viterbo% | W | 1-0 | ||||
| Grand View% | L | 0-5 | ||||
| *Midwest Classic Conference | ||||||
| %MCC Tournament | ||||||
| Head Coach: Kevin Rushing | ||||||
| Record: 10-10 (3-4 MCC) | ||||||