| All-Americans | ||||
| 2002 | HM-Trisha Merrill | |||
| 2003 | HM-Trisha Merrill | |||
| 2004 | HM-Trisha Merrill | |||
| All-Conference | ||||
| 1996 | 2nd-Jana Snyder | |||
| 2000 | 1st-Talia Roberts | |||
| 1st-Sara Ridley | ||||
| 1st-Amanda Woods | ||||
| 2nd-Krystal Hamik | ||||
| 2nd-Courtney Robinson | ||||
| Note: Penn changed to NAIA/MCC in 2001 | ||||
| 2001 | 1st-Shay Hansen | |||
| 1st-Kristen Tesch | ||||
| 1st-Kelli Crooks | ||||
| 2nd-Megan Degering | ||||
| 2nd-Trisha Merrill | ||||
| 2nd-Sarah Ridley | ||||
| HM-Sarah Rodriguez | ||||
| 2002 | 1st-Sarah Ridley | |||
| 1st-Kelli Crooks | ||||
| 1st-Megan DeGering | ||||
| 1st-Aundralise Nistler | ||||
| 1st-Trisha Merrill | ||||
| 1st-Ember Shaner | ||||
| 2nd-Tiffany Forrest | ||||
| 2nd-Kate Baugh | ||||
| 2003 | 1st-Ashley Gerace | |||
| 1st-Trisha Merrill | ||||
| 1st-Sarah Wall | ||||
| 2nd-Analeigh Maxfield | ||||
| 2nd-Cathy Dragna | ||||
| HM-Danielle Urban | ||||
| HM-Aundralise Nistler | ||||
| HM-Katie Miller | ||||
| 2004 | 1st-Kelli Crooks | |||
| 1st-Analeigh Maxfield | ||||
| 1st-Trisha Merrill | ||||
| 1st-Katie Miller | ||||
| 2nd-Lindsay Hough | ||||
| 2nd-Nicole Freeman | ||||
| 2nd-Cami Bangasser | ||||
| HM-Danielle Urban | ||||
| Player of the Year-Trisha Merrill | ||||
| 2005 | 1st-Megan Barnes | |||
| 1st-Nicole Freeman | ||||
| 1st-Lindsay Hough | ||||
| 1st-Kim Quijano | ||||
| HM-Kelli Crooks | ||||
| 2006 | 1st-Kim Quijano | |||
| 1st-Whitney Withrow. | ||||
| 2nd-Cassie Bowman | ||||
| HM-Tammy Fox | ||||
| HM-Jen Hart | ||||
| Newcomer of the Year-Cassie Bowman | ||||