| ALL-AMERICANS | |
| PLAYER | YEAR |
| Jan Irby | 1974-75 |
| Susie Kudrna | 1975-76 |
| Glenda Poock | 1978-79 |
| Becky King | 1980-81 1st team |
| Rae White | 1980-81 2nd team |
| Lori Myers | 1981-82 1st team |
| Lori Busch | 1981-82 Honorable Mention |
| Rae White | 1981-82 Honorable Mention |
| Leslie Spencer | 1982-83 1st team |
| Becky Inman | 1985-86 2nd team |
| Becky Inman | 1986-87 1st team |
| Nicki Baldwin | 1990-91 1st team AWSF |
| ALL-CONFERENCE | |
| PLAYER | YEAR |
| Leslie Spencer | 1982-83 First Iowa Conference MVP |
| Robin Rich | 1983-84 1st team |
| Margaret Hearne | 1983-84 2nd team |
| Becky Inman | 1983-84 2nd team |
| Becky Inman | 1983-85 2nd team |
| Robin Rich-Taylor | 1984-85 1st team |
| Becky Inman | 1984-85 2nd team |
| Cindy McCarthy | 1985-86 1st team |
| Becky Inman | 1985-86 1st team |
| Becky Inman | 1986-87 IIAC MVP, 1st team |
| Theresa Mastrogiovani | 1987-88 1st team |
| Andrea Moore | 1987-88 2nd team |
| Veronica Viet | 1988-89 2nd team |
| Nicki Baldwin | 1989-90 1st team |
| Gina Sisk | 1989-90 2nd team |
| Nicki Baldwin | 1990-91 IIAC MVP, 1st team |
| Jill Burson | 1991-92 2nd team |
| Kristin Waterbeck | 1992-93 2nd team |
| Jennifer Chambers | 1993-94 1st team |
| Jennifer Chambers | 1994-95 1st team |
| Sue Spielbauer | 1995-96 2nd team |
| Sue Spielbauer | 1996-97 2nd team |
| Carey Hunt | 1999-2000 1st team |
| Wendy Lautner | 2000-01 2nd team |
| Kim Morrill | 2001-02 1st team* |
| Christine Weingart | 2002-03 1st team |
| Kristina McNew | 2003-04 1st team |
| Ciara Laboy | 2003-04 Honorable Mention |
| Christine Weingart | 2003-04 Honorable Mention |
| Trista Kolder | 2004-05 1st Team |
| Kari Boscaljon | 2004-05 Honorable Mention |
| Kristina McNew | 2004-05 Honorable Mention |
| Angela Bourrage | 2005-06 Honorable Mention |
| April Love | 2005-06 Honorable Mention |
| Latasha Pendleton | 2005-06 Honorable Mention |
| Carrie Parker | 2007-08 Honorable Mention |
| Christa Subbert | 2007-08 Honorable Mention |
| *Penn moved to NAIA in 2001-2002 | |