| All-American | |||||||
| 1897 | John Outland | ||||||
| 1898 | John Outland | ||||||
| 1959 | Jack Boender | ||||||
| 1960 | Jack Boender | ||||||
| 1969 | Wilbur Young | ||||||
| 1970 | Bruce Polen | ||||||
| Wilbur Young | |||||||
| 1971 | Bruce Polen | ||||||
| 1974 | Bill Cronin | ||||||
| 1975 | John Jenkins (1st) | ||||||
| Jim Dulin (2nd) | |||||||
| Gail Gustafson (HM) | |||||||
| Mike Mitchell (HM) | |||||||
| Jeff Parsons (HM) | |||||||
| 1983 | Jim Portese | ||||||
| Note: Penn joined NAIA in 2001 | |||||||
| 2001 | Donald Carpenter (HM) | ||||||
| AJ Novak (HM) | |||||||
| 2002 | AJ Novak (2nd) | ||||||
| 2003 | Chas Ryan (HM) | ||||||
| 2004 | James Fountaine (2nd) | ||||||
| Chas Ryan (HM) | |||||||
| Andy Stokes (HM) | |||||||
| 2005 | James Jackson (HM) | ||||||
| 2006 | James Jackson (2nd, VSN; HM, Don Hansen's) | ||||||
| Clint Peery (2nd, VSN & Don Hansen's) | |||||||
| All-Conference | |||||||
| 1923 | Lisle Ware (End) | ||||||
| 1924 | Lisle Ware (End) | ||||||
| ??? Cook (Guard) | |||||||
| 1925 | John Rafferty (Fullback) | ||||||
| 1926 | ??? Green (Guard) | ||||||
| 1930 | Avon Covey (Quarterback) | ||||||
| 1931 | ??? Swan (End) | ||||||
| 1933 | John Bell (Center) | ||||||
| 1939 | Charles Bainbridge (Halfback) | ||||||
| 1940 | Charles Bainbridge (Halfback) | ||||||
| Note: From 1950-1961, Penn was not in Iowa Conference | |||||||
| 1962 | Larry Almond (Defensive Tackle) | ||||||
| Ron Randleman (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Chuck Henry (Running Back) | |||||||
| 1963 | Jim Freeze (Running Back) | ||||||
| 1965 | Chuck Henry (Running Back) | ||||||
| 1966 | Ed Williamson (End) | ||||||
| Tom Barnes (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| 1967 | Tom Barnes (Offensive Line) | ||||||
| Dave Cozart (Running Back) | |||||||
| Wilbur Young (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Note: Beginning in 1968, the IIAC began using 1st and 2nd teams | |||||||
| 1968 | First Team | ||||||
| Buddy White (Running Back) | |||||||
| Dick Wells (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Ed Williamson (End) | |||||||
| Tom Johnson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jim Duede (Linebacker) | |||||||
| 1969 | First Team | ||||||
| Tom Johnson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Ray Houghtling (Defensive Tackle) | |||||||
| Jerry Bailey (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Frank Martucci (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Wilbur Young (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| John Roman (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Dick Bye (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1970 | First Team | ||||||
| Larry Nolan (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Wilbur Young (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Dick Barber (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Tom Fontana (Running Back) | |||||||
| John Roman (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Mike Van Cleave (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Bruce Polen (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1971 | First Team | ||||||
| Larry Nolan (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| John LaPointe (Defensive End) | |||||||
| David Scott (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Mike Van Cleave (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Bruce Polen (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Tom Fontana (Running Back) | |||||||
| DeWayne Hogan (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Greg Hafner (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Greg Lang (Running Back) | |||||||
| 1972 | First Team | ||||||
| Bill Cronin (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Larry Noland (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Greg Lang (Running Back) | |||||||
| John LaPointe (Defensive End) | |||||||
| David Scott (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Linn Crawn (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Bruce Polen (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Greg Hafner (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Dave Gustafson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Mike Jepson (Running Back) | |||||||
| Dick Barber (Linebacker) | |||||||
| 1973 | First Team | ||||||
| Gail Gustafson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Bill Cronin (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jim Brokaw (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Carl Johnson (Running Back) | |||||||
| Linn Crawn (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| John Roberts (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Dennis Lorenc (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1974 | First Team | ||||||
| Bill Cronin (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Gail Gustafson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jim Brokaw (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Carl Johnson (Running Back) | |||||||
| Tim Mattern (Running Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Jeff Parsons (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Vine Edwards (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Ray Roewe (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Gordon Roth (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| John Jenkins (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| 1975 | First Team | ||||||
| Roger McGee (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Gail Gustafson (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jim Dulin (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Jeff Parsons (Quarterback)* | |||||||
| Jim Goerss (Running Back) | |||||||
| Mike Mitchell (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| John Jenkins (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Walt Kosman (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Gordon Roth (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1976 | First Team | ||||||
| Brian Byers (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jim Dulin (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Jim Goerss (Running Back) | |||||||
| Kenny Van Dusseldorp (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Randy Ripperger (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Mike Mitchell (Defensive Line)* | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Randy McCurry (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Tim Mattern (Running Back) | |||||||
| Herb Mayo (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Danny Witthoff (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Ross Cameron (Linebacker) | |||||||
| 1977 | First Team | ||||||
| Jim Goerss (Running Back) | |||||||
| Kevin Baker (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Raiford Hursey (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Ross Cameron (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Herb Mayo (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| 1978 | First Team | ||||||
| Don Kent (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Kevin Baker (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Dave McMullin (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Randy McCurry (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Ben Beaman (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Randy Ripperger (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1979 | Second Team | ||||||
| Rusty Schroeder (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| 1980 | First Team | ||||||
| Rich Baskerville (Running Back) | |||||||
| Jim Portese (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Greg Wittmer (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Tim Christopher (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Dave Angelhow (Defensive End) | |||||||
| 1981 | First Team | ||||||
| Jim Portese (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Dave Angelhow (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Rodney Walls (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Kevin Mimms (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Ross Adler (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Rich Baskerville (Running Back) | |||||||
| Robert Blades (Linebacker) | |||||||
| 1982 | Second Team | ||||||
| Jim Portese (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| 1983 | First Team | ||||||
| Robert Blades (Defensive End) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Greg Peeples (Running Back) | |||||||
| Mike Gottman (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Larry Tupy (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| 1984 | First Team | ||||||
| Larry Tupy (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Joey Townsell (Running Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Mike Emendorfer (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Ron Kunecke (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Mike Higgins (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1985 | First Team | ||||||
| Troy Waters (Tight End) | |||||||
| Mike Emendorfer (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Darryl Kosut (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Larry Tupy (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Mike Higgins (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1986 | First Team | ||||||
| Darryl Kosut (Quarterback)* | |||||||
| Phil Lite (Placekicker) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Larry Kerr (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Paul Williams (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Ed Pittman (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Frank Carbone (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1987 | First Team | ||||||
| Henry Bauman (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Larry Kerr (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Morgan Rowell (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| 1988 | First Team | ||||||
| Lance Hindt (Punter) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Lance Hindt (Linebacker) | |||||||
| 1989 | First Team | ||||||
| Lance Hindt (Punter) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Dave Mallow (Tight End) | |||||||
| 1990 | First Team | ||||||
| Brian Sarver (Punter) | |||||||
| 1991 | First Team | ||||||
| Andy Pickering (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Brian Sarver (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| 1992 | First Team | ||||||
| Dusty Schroeder (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Brian Sarver (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| 1993 | Second Team | ||||||
| Rye Link (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 1996 | Second Team | ||||||
| Rick Rawlings (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Paul Jones (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| 1997 | Second Team | ||||||
| Dustin Dobbins (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Note: Penn joined Mid-States Football Association in 2002 | |||||||
| 2002 | First Team | ||||||
| AJ Novak (Linebacker) | |||||||
| David Ignash (Punter) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Donald Carpenter (Running Back) | |||||||
| Chas Ryan (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Fred Brown (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Clay Henderson (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Samuel Smith (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Andy Stokes (Tight End) | |||||||
| Torain Howard (Running Back) | |||||||
| Tom Campos (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Jimmy Bara (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Joe Illingworth (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Matt Forbes (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 2003 | First Team | ||||||
| Chas Ryan (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Patrick Baker (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Andy Stokes (Tight End) | |||||||
| James Fountaine (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Clint Ray (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Troy Braithwaite (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Rob Freeman (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Corey Allen (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Corey Randall (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Michael Robinson (Tight End) | |||||||
| Kentrell Jones (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Lee Davis (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| 2004 | First Team | ||||||
| Chas Ryan (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Andy Stokes (Tight End) | |||||||
| James Fountain (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Clint Ray (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Sonny Amaama (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Kentrell Jones (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Derrick Swanigan (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Steve Kaster (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Robert Freeman (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Emmanuel Howard (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 2005 | First Team | ||||||
| James Jackson (Running Back) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Clint Peery (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Clint Ray (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jared Jensen (Tight End) | |||||||
| Corey Allen (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| Lee Davis (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Bryant Gregory (Defensive Line) | |||||||
| Novarro Emery (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Kentrell Jones (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Tim Atwater (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Derek Doran (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Tim Tuck (Defensive Back) | |||||||
| 2006 | First Team | ||||||
| James Jackson (Running Back) | |||||||
| Clint Peery (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Lee Davis (Nose Tackle) | |||||||
| Michael Robinson (Tight End) | |||||||
| George Smith (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Cale Carlson (Cornerback) | |||||||
| Skyler Crouch (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Chris Minton (Defensive Tackle) | |||||||
| Antoine Murray (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Blandon Prowse (Defensive End) | |||||||
| 2007 | First Team | ||||||
| Cale Carlson (Cornerback) | |||||||
| Mark Gronzalski (Punter) | |||||||
| Second Team | |||||||
| Mario Whitney (Running Back) | |||||||
| Clint Peery (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Antoine Murray (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Honorable Mention | |||||||
| Skyler Crouch (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Adam Randall (Wide Receiver) | |||||||
| Ryan Van Dalen (Quarterback) | |||||||
| Steven Dawley (Offensive Line) | |||||||
| Jake Jenkins (Free Safety) | |||||||
| Travis Grosshans (Linebacker) | |||||||
| Brad Fite (Defensive End) | |||||||