| Passing | |||||
| Longest Touchdown Pass | |||||
| Yards | Receiver | Passer | Year | Opponent | |
| 84 | Adam Randall | Ryan Van Dalen | 2007 | Iowa Wesleyan | |
| 82 | Jim Dulin | Jeff Parsons | 1974 | Luther | |
| 82 | Paul Williams | O.J. McGhee | 1987 | Buena Vista | |
| 82 | Tarvar Baskerville | Matt Randolph | 1997 | Central Methodist | |
| 81 | Lloyd Nolen | Mike Caba | 1998 | Coe | |
| 81 | Lloyd Nolen | Mike Caba | 1998 | Coe | |
| 80 | Wes Rice | Brian Sarver | 1990 | Luther | |
| 80 | Kelly Battle | Joey Poretto | 1996 | Simpson | |
| 79 | Rodney Olson | Jim Dulin | 1975 | Simpson | |
| 79 | Quarnail Arnold | Mike Caba | 1998 | Cornell | |
| 79 | Quarnail Arnold | Mike Caba | 1998 | Cornell | |
| Pass Attempts | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 67 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 59 | Darryl Kosut | 1985 | Dubuque | ||
| 57 | K.C. Church | 1999 | Luther | ||
| 56 | Mike Marsh | 1992 | Coe | ||
| 54 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Luther | ||
| 54 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Graceland | ||
| 53 | K.C. Church | 1999 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 51 | K.C. Church | 1999 | Simpson | ||
| 50 | Mike Caba | 1998 | Buena Vista | ||
| 49 | Kentrell Jones | 2003 | St. Francis (Ind.) | ||
| Pass Completions | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 36 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 28 | Kentrell Jones | 2004 | Trinity International | ||
| 28 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Luther | ||
| 25 | Kentrell Jones | 2003 | St. Francis (Ind.) | ||
| 24 | Jared Jensen | 2004 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 23 | Darryl Kosut | 1984 | Wartburg | ||
| 23 | Darryl Kosut | 1985 | Dubuque | ||
| 23 | Darryl Kosut | 1985 | Wartburg | ||
| 23 | Mike Caba | 1997 | MacMurray | ||
| 22 | Kentrell Jones | 2003 | Quincy | ||
| 22 | Darryl Kosut | 1985 | Luther | ||
| 22 | Darryl Kosut | 1986 | Central | ||
| 22 | Corey Schlicher | 1987 | Wartburg | ||
| Passing Yards | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 443 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 427 | Michael Caba | 1998 | Cornell | ||
| 347 | Kentrell Jones | 2004 | Trinity International | ||
| 336 | Michael Caba | 1998 | Wartburg | ||
| 334 | Kentrell Jones | 2004 | St. Ambrose | ||
| 313 | Ryan Van Dalen | 2007 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 309 | Kentrell Jones | 2003 | Drake | ||
| 305 | Michael Caba | 1997 | MacMurray | ||
| 297 | Kentrell Jones | 2003 | St. Francis (Ind.) | ||
| 294 | Darryl Kosut | 1984 | Luther | ||
| Passing Touchdowns | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 4 | Mike Caba | 1998 | Cornell | ||
| 4 | Jared Jensen | 2003 | Trinity International | ||
| 4 | Darryl Kosut | 1984 | Luther | ||
| 4 | Darryl Kosut | 1984 | Coe | ||
| 4 | Jeff Parsons | 1974 | Luther | ||
| 4 | Jeff Parsons | 1975 | Central | ||
| 4 | Andy Pickering | 1991 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 3 | Numerous | ||||
| Rushing | |||||
| Longest Touchdown Run | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 92 | Donald Carpenter | 2001 | Bethel | ||
| 89 | Pete Raskis | 1965 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 87 | Kegan Franklin | 1993 | Central | ||
| 85 | Jim Goerss | 1976 | Wartburg | ||
| 81 | Tequil Franklin | 1996 | Dubuque | ||
| 81 | Charles Lovelady | 1993 | Coe | ||
| 80 | Mike Caba | 1998 | Dubuque | ||
| 80 | Buddy White | 1968 | Buena Vista | ||
| 79 | Charles Bainbridge | 1939 | Wartburg | ||
| 78 | Mike Kauzlarich | 1980 | Buena Vista | ||
| 76 | Brad Hauscheldt | 1985 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 75 | Mike Sash | 1973 | Luther | ||
| Rushing Attempts | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | |||
| 51 | James Jackson | 2005 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 43 | James Jackson | 2006 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 38 | Donald Carpenter | 2001 | Virginia Wise | ||
| 36 | James Jackson | 2005 | McKendree | ||
| 35 | James Jackson | 2006 | Saint Xavier | ||
| 35 | James Jackson | 2006 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 35 | James Jackson | 2005 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 33 | Joe Townsell | 1985 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 33 | Joe Townsell | 1984 | Simpson | ||
| 33 | Donald Carpenter | 2002 | Southern Nazarene | ||
| Rushing Yards | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 297 | Donald Carpenter | 2001 | Mt. Senario | ||
| 268 | Tequil Franklin | 1996 | Dubuque | ||
| 268 | James Jackson | 2005 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 254 | Carl Johnson | 1974 | Graceland | ||
| 253 | Jack Boender | 1960 | Principa | ||
| 250 | Donald Carpenter | 2001 | Bethel | ||
| 248 | Jim Goerss | 1976 | Simpson | ||
| 247 | Frank Guthrie | 1971 | Doane | ||
| 238 | Jim Goerss | 1976 | Saginaw Valley State | ||
| 226 | Ephraim Twillie | 2000 | Dubuque | ||
| Receiving | |||||
| Receiving Yards | |||||
| Yds. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 183 | James Fountaine | 2004 | Trinity International | ||
| 183 | Skyler Crouch | 2007 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 166 | Jim Rice | 1990 | Luther | ||
| 166 | Adam Randall | 2007 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 163 | Adam Randall | 2007 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 162 | James Fountaine | 2004 | St. Ambrose | ||
| 161 | Lloyd Holen | 1998 | Coe | ||
| 155 | Paul Williams | 1986 | Central | ||
| 151 | Jason Maeder | 1992 | Loras | ||
| 146 | James Fountaine | 2004 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| Receptions | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 12 | Mike Emendorfer | 1985 | Luther | ||
| 12 | Morgan Rowell | 1987 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 11 | Adam Randall | 2007 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 11 | Quarnail Arnold | 1999 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 11 | Mike Emendorfer | 1985 | Dubuque | ||
| 11 | James Fountaine | 2004 | Olivet Nazarene | ||
| 11 | James Fountaine | 2004 | Trinity International | ||
| 11 | Morgan Rowell | 1987 | Wartburg | ||
| 10 | Brian Sarver | 1991 | Luther | ||
| 9 | Numerous | ||||
| Kicking | |||||
| Longest Field Goal | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 58 | Mike Riordan | 1983 | Wartburg | ||
| 57 | Mike Riordan | 1984 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 52 | Tom Fulcher | 1990 | Buena Vista | ||
| 48 | Randy Dunn | 1976 | Luther | ||
| 47 | Randy Dunn | 1976 | Simpson | ||
| 47 | Todd Jones | 1979 | Simpson | ||
| 47 | Steve Quintero | 2004 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 46 | William Brasel | 2007 | Trinity International | ||
| 45 | Ed Wright | 1917 | Monmouth | ||
| 45 | Ryan Baker | 2001 | Midland Lutheran | ||
| Returns | |||||
| Longest Kickoff Return for a TD | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 97 | A.J. Littlejohn | 2006 | St. Francis (Ind.) | ||
| 95 | Jerry Bailey | 1969 | Dubuque | ||
| 95 | Kevin Mims | 1979 | Luther | ||
| 94 | Rodney Olson | 1975 | Buena Vista | ||
| 93 | Torain Howard | 2001 | Midland Lutheran | ||
| 91 | Tequil Franklin | 1996 | Simpson | ||
| 89 | Kevin Mimms | 1981 | Wartburg | ||
| 85 | Jim Goerss | 1976 | Dubuque | ||
| 85 | Brent Blanchard | 1988 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 83 | Torain Howard | 2001 | Bacone | ||
| 83 | Jim Dulin | 1976 | Wartburg | ||
| Longest Punt Return for a TD | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 95 | Al Smith | 1909 | Central | ||
| 95 | Brian Sarver | 1992 | Dubuque | ||
| 70 | Lucius Ashby | 1922 | Central | ||
| 67 | Ken Konopasek | 1986 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 65 | Mike Sash | 1972 | Missouri Western | ||
| 65 | Al Smith | 1909 | Central | ||
| 55 | Randy Ripperger | 1975 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 55 | Tommy Schneider | 1976 | Central | ||
| 50 | Matt Forbes | 2002 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 40 | Bruce Polen | 1971 | Simpson | ||
| 40 | Bob Starkey | 1974 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| Scoring | |||||
| Touchdowns | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 5 | Tequil Franklin | 1996 | Dubuque | ||
| 4 | Frank Guthrie | 1971 | Doane | ||
| 4 | Donald Carpenter | 2001 | Mt. Senario | ||
| 4 | Carl Johnson | 1972 | Baker | ||
| 4 | Dole Macy | 1916 | Central | ||
| 4 | Brian Sarver | 1992 | Dubuque | ||
| 3 | Numerous | ||||
| Defensive | |||||
| Longest Interception Return for a TD | |||||
| Yards | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 95 | Floyd (Pat) Patterson | 1924 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 93 | Griff Wright | 1916 | Central | ||
| 88 | Parrish Copeland | 1988 | Simpson | ||
| 88 | Rodney Walls | 1981 | Upper Iowa | ||
| 77 | Jim Arsenault | 1959 | Eureka | ||
| 70 | Jimmy Quire | 1927 | Simpson | ||
| 67 | Ben Saville | 1956 | Burlington JC | ||
| 67 | Buddy White | 1966 | Buena Vista | ||
| 66 | Avon Covey | 1928 | Parsons | ||
| 62 | John McElvaney | 1998 | Upper Iowa | ||
| Tackles | |||||
| Since 2001 | |||||
| No. | Name | Year | Opponent | ||
| 28 | Patrick Baker | 2003 | St. Xavier | ||
| 22 | Marty DeCamp | 2001 | McKendree | ||
| 21 | A.J. Novak | 2001 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 21 | A.J. Novak | 2002 | Trinity International | ||
| 21 | Chas Ryan | 2002 | McKendree | ||
| 21 | Patrick Baker | 2003 | McKendree | ||
| 21 | Clint Peery | 2007 | McKendree | ||
| 19 | A.J. Novak | 2001 | McKendree | ||
| 19 | A.J. Novak | 2002 | St. Francis (Ill.) | ||
| 19 | Clint Peery | 2005 | Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| 18 | Derek Doran | 2003 | St. Xavier | ||